M. E. Fuller

Death in Paradise

By M. E. Fuller

This book is dedicated to my family. Without them, my work would not have been possible. Also, this book is fiction. Any similarity to people living or dead is a coincidence.

Prologue

The room Fallon had expected to find dark was filled with light and life. Her husband stood busily before their kitchen stove. He was not a tall man but he had a quiet, confident manner she had found comforting.

He wore a loose sweatshirt and jeans. Dappled sunlight played across his shoulders and back. The morning smells of bacon and coffee and toast filled the room.

She stepped past the doorway. He turned toward her and smiled -- his face a medley of tenderness, passion, and love

"I thought you were gone," she said.

"I know."

"But these past years? Those long, unbearable last months?"

"They’re behind us," he said softly.

Fallon wondered how the ordeal could be over. It still seemed so real to her. She could remember its beginning to the day. Adam had just come through their rear door. She had been baking. The room smelled of chocolate chip cookies.

She had turned from the sink at the sound of the door opening and she had watched with a smile as Adam had removed his gloves, coat, and muffler. Slowly, as he had quietly unbundled himself, she had realized something was vitally wrong and her smile had faded.

"What did he say then?" she had asked wiping her wet hands on a dishtowel.

"It isn’t good, Fallon."

"What do you mean, it’s not good?"

Adam had complained for months of not feeling well. It had been nothing he could quite put into precise words but was rather a general feeling of malaise. She had finally convinced him to go see a doctor. Something Adam disdained.

She had offered to go with him. It was an offer he had instantly pushed aside--a fact, at that moment, which Fallon deeply resented.

Had he allowed her to go with him, she would not have been standing there waiting for news, news he obviously did not want to give.

"It’s cancer. A rare form. The prognosis is not good."

But Fallon abhorred death--an aversion that had started when her father had died on her twelfth birthday. Since then, she had routinely railed against death. It was what had driven her into her life-long profession.

"We’ll fight it," she had told him.

But that was then. And this was now. She heard a cardinal song through the open kitchen window, felt the warmth of summer around her, and Adam stood quietly before their stove. He was the picture of health.

He moved to her. She hesitated then stepped forward, too. He wrapped his arms round her. They kissed. His mouth warm, his arms as familiar to her as the sound of her own heart beat.

"I’ve missed you so much." She rested her head against his broad shoulder, drawing strength from the press of his body against hers.

Chapter 1

Fallon Magare forced her eyes open. Beside her the telephone shrieked. She wished its ringing would cease. She longed to return to her dream.

In the days to come, she would occasionally regret not giving in to that instinct. But duty was duty. When the phone rang, a sheriff answered the call.

So she eased her arms from beneath the covers, heaved onto an elbow, and grabbed the receiver with her free hand.

"Sheriff Magare," she mumbled into the mouthpiece.

"Ah, Fallon," a deep voice rumbled. "I’m sorry to call at this hour, but we need you. We’ve got a dead body. An obvious homicide."

"Where?"

"Out on County Road 650 East. Matty Williams’ place. I’ll explain later."

"I’ll be right there," Fallon ran a hand through her matted hair, "twenty minutes max."

She signed off, replaced the receiver, and lay quietly a moment, giving her startled mind a chance to focus. Her eyes studied the blank ceiling. The room she woke to was dark. Lined drapes banned all but a faint suggestion of sunlight from the room.

Beyond the windows, the heat of late August droned on. Even at that early hour, late-summer Midwestern humidity bore down on corn fields and bean fields surrounding the town. In town, air conditioners hummed with abandon.

The sheriff sat up and pushed herself off from her bed. She rushed through her morning ritual, slapping cold water onto her face, and running a brush through her short hair.

Her uniform with its brown shirt and matching skirt was draped over the back of a chair in her bedroom. Underwear and socks were stacked on the chair seat. Heavy brown, sensible shoes sat to the front of the chair. Fallon Magare was prepared to begin a day quickly.

Alone in the darkened bedroom the silence of the house pressed against her. Normally at this hour, she would have turned on the television. The radio in the kitchen. Anything to submerge the silence of living alone.

As she donned her uniform, she struggled to shake off the feeling of loneliness -- the lingering sense of abandonment. Finally dressed, she grabbed car keys from the bedroom dresser and fled her silent home.

*****

The drive to Matty Williams’ field took Fallon less than ten minutes. Windtree County was of medium size geographically. Nestled on the Illinois side of the Mississippi River, it encompassed about six hundred square miles, contained six towns, and had a population of little more than twenty-five thousand.

Matty Williams' farm sat near the northeast corner of the county about as far from the river as one could get. The land there was flat, rich, and fertile. It was good farm ground, which had for generations provided its owners with comfortable incomes.

Turning left off County Road 650 East, Fallon eased her Jeep through an open gate and into a harvested oat field. She switched off the ignition, stepped down from the Wrangler, and walked slowly toward the far edge of the field.

Four men from the Illinois State Police were already at work there. They were members of the state’s tech squad. They handled crime scene investigations for small counties that could not afford their own experts. Bob Jeswalt was the unit’s lead investigator.

"Hi Fallon," Jeswalt said looking up when she reached his side. "Sorry to have called you so early." Jeswalt was a large man with dark brown eyes, square jaw, and cleft chin. In his mid-forties, he had the body of a weight lifter gone soft with age.

It had been an early morning for both of them. Normally fastidious in his appearance, Fallon saw on his chin stray wisps of whiskers highlighted in the bright sunlight. They had apparently been missed in his rush to respond to an early morning phone call.

"Hello, Bob." Fallon answered. In her early forties with a short round body, but also with wide-set and intelligent-looking gray eyes, she was one of only a hand-full of women to serve as a sheriff. And in Windtree County, she was the first ever.

She knew all eyes in the county and even beyond it would be centered on her actions over the next few days or weeks.

"So do we know who we've got here?" she asked.

Jeswalt rose from beside the bloated corpse.

"It’s Olny Parkman. The corpse has been out here so long, I almost wouldn’t have known him if he hadn’t been wearing that damn belt buckle. Always claimed it was his good luck charm." He gave a swift shake of his head.

Magare glanced at the buckle. It was large and made of silver and decorated with turquoise and red-onyx stones--an odd talisman to serve as an identity marker in death.

The body lay on its right side. A thick cord bound its hands and feet. A short strip of duct tape sealed its mouth. Blood had spilt from a gaping throat wound and had dried in a puddle to the right of the body.

Spikes of dried oat stubble protruded from within the crusted brown blood. The few broken oat straws surrounding the body suggested the elderly man had not fought hard when death came.

"Got any theories on what happened here?" Magare finally asked lifting her gaze to Jeswalt. He had been first to the scene. But death had come in an unincorporated field in Windtree County. The responsibility for the murder investigation was hers.

"Not much more than you can see for yourself. Throat’s been slashed. Looks like he’s been dead about three days . . . maybe more. So decayed, I doubt we’ll know anything more definite than that even after the coroner finishes with him."

"You’ve called him, right?"

Jeswalt nodded.

Magare let her eyes study the barren field around them. The piece of ground the body lay in protruded eastward and turned north, like a hook, from the edge of a field that was otherwise square. Its view from the road was partially hidden by old-growth forest.

"Looks like whoever brought him here knew what he was doing. It’s a sheltered place. Good cover for a murder," she mumbled stuffing her hands into the pockets of her twill skirt.

"Hmm," Jeswalt answered. "Not sure the murderer knew that. We’ve got stubble broken all around the field. Looks like whoever did this probably drove around a bit before finding this spot."

"Maybe," Fallon nodded. "Or maybe that’s what the murderer wanted us to think." She let the issue go. She knew it was the kind of detail that only fell into place with time. "Any tire prints?"

Jeswalt shook his head. "Too dry. Ground’s too hard to leave tracks."

"What was in his pockets?"

"Nothing."

"Nothing?"

Magare forced her gaze back to the corpse. It was fully dressed in chinos and a plaid shirt. Jeswalt's news seemed to go against basic logic.

Reason told her that most men put things in their pockets when they put on their pants. Car keys, wallet, loose change. Even after a robbery, there was usually something to be found in a victim’s pockets.

"Think maybe Olny was forced to dress in a hurry? Maybe he’d been in bed when the killer attacked him?" Magare looked back up at Jeswalt, who, at six-one, towered over her. "That could explain the empty pockets."

"That’s possible," Jeswalt agreed. "There’s no doubt, though, that he was killed here. It’s not a case of a dead body being moved."

Fallon stood quietly, her mind imaging an aged man, rousted from sleep, dragged half way across the county to have his throat slashed.

She wondered if he had been aware of his impending fate. Had he known terror throughout the entire drive? Or had he been an unsuspecting victim, someone who believed the driver beside him wished him no harm? She shivered.

"Who found the body?" She returned her attention to Jeswalt.

"Milton Canfield. You know him?"

Fallon nodded. "He and I went to school together."

"Well, he farms this land for Matty. Said he was coming in this morning to mow along the fences and decided to hit the grass along the forest first."

She wondered why Milt had reported the corpse to State Police rather than to her office. As she wrestled with that question, she struggled to keep her face blank. The last thing she would want Jeswalt to guess is that she took the oversight personally.

Reaching into her skirt pocket, she drew out a wide, cotton handkerchief. She lifted her broad-brimmed hat and wiped sweat from her brow. It was early morning but the day’s heat was already stifling.

"Where’s Milt?" She asked glancing around the field at the trucks and vans parked there.

"Turned green. Said he was going home. I told him that wasn't allowed. He just snorted and said if we wanted to arrest him that was fine. He'd take his chances."

"I’ll need to talk to him."

"He knows that. I told him you’d be setting up a meet."

Fallon struggled for a breath. She wished for a moment that she were younger. Humidity hadn’t seemed to bother her so much then.

"I take it there’s no sign of the murder weapon."

"Not that we’ve found yet. I’m sending my men into the woods next, though. Maybe the murderer threw the knife away there where it’d be tougher to find. But you’re right. We’re probably not going to find it."

"Which way did the driver get in? Can you tell?"

Bob Jeswalt pointed toward County Highway 650 East. "Same way you came in. Right through that gate in the fence."

Fallon turned on her heel and glanced back toward the roadway. The field was bordered by a low, rusting fence. A gray weathered gate hung open about midway along the fence line. She wondered if the gate was normally closed and locked.

Turning back to Jeswalt, she suddenly noted the dark circles beneath his eyes and deep lines surrounding his mouth. She knew it was more than just being called out early that had put those creases of care on his otherwise smooth features.

"How’s Ellie?" she asked.

"Oh, about as good as can be expected," Jeswalt answered with a short, swift shake of his head. His wife had been diagnosed with cancer nearly three weeks ago. Since then, the woman had started long, uncomfortable radiation treatments with only a small chance for success.

"Tell her I’ll be over to see her next week," Magare said, returning the handkerchief to her skirt pocket. She knew what Bob and Ellie were going through. Fallon had lost her husband to cancer just two years ago. Dying, as she well knew, could be a long, lonely affair--for both partners.

"I’ll tell her you’ll be by," Jeswalt answered with a curt nod. "She’ll be glad for the company."

Behind them they heard the roar of a motor and turned to see the large, white coroner’s van pulling into the field. They watched as the coroner steered his way toward them and braked to a stop.

Jeswalt and Magare stepped back to escape the dust cloud his vehicle had raised in the rain-parched field. The driver’s door swung open and a thin man with balding black hair emerged from the van.

Who ya’ got here?" Windtree County Coroner Harold Peters asked as he turned to slam the van door closed.

"It’s Olny Parkman," Jeswalt answered.

Peters scurried toward them with his gaze fastened on the corpse.

"Parkman, huh?" He stopped several feet from the body. "Who’d want him dead? Even if they did, why kill him? Had to be nearly ninety. Seems like he’d have died soon enough. Not much need to help him along. Not at his age."

Fallon raised and lowered her shoulders. "If you’ve got any suggestions, I’m listening."

Peters studied the sheriff’s face closely. Magare squirmed under his gaze.

"Too bad our last sheriff died so soon after retiring," Peters said, shoving his hands into his pants pocket. "He knew the county. Gonna be tough to break this case for somebody who doesn’t."

Magare considered telling Peters that she knew the county too. She had been born here. She had grown up here. But she had also lived away from it for the last twenty-some years. Her absence was a weakness--a dent in her political armor.

She decided to let his comment go unanswered and turned back to Jeswalt. "How long before your men can get over to Parkman’s house?" Olny, they all knew, had lived in Paradise.

The lead crime-scene technician glanced at his watch. "I can probably cut Randy and Steve loose right away if you want."

"No rush," Fallon answered. "I’ll meet them over there . . . say . . . in about twenty-five minutes?"

"You got it."

"Thanks," Fallon answered with a smile. "And Harold," she said turning toward the aging coroner, "I need whatever information you can get me on this as soon as possible."

"I’ll take the body to the Springfield lab. They’re quick . . . and thorough."

"Thank you. I appreciate that," she said with relief. Although he had pierced her with his barb about knowing the county, he apparently didn’t plan to actively block her investigation.

"If you’d both fax your reports over to my office when they’re done, I’d appreciate it," she said, her voice measured. "Now I’m not saying I’d liked to have had them yesterday but it’s close."

Both men responded with grim smiles and curt nods.

*****

Fallon said her farewells and walked slowly back to her Jeep parked at the far end of the field. It was simply too hot to rush. The Wrangler was her personal vehicle, and its keys had been the first ones she had grabbed that morning. She also knew driving it to the murder scene had been a mistake.

She stopped a moment and examined the fence gate and its lock. The padlock was old but unmarked. There were no indications it had been forced. Then, she straightened and returned to her original path toward the car.

Stepping up into the driver’s seat, she quickly switched on the ignition, shoved the gearshift into first, and gunned her way out of the field. Behind her loose gravel spun into the air. She turned the Jeep left onto County Road 650 East and headed home.

As she drove, her thoughts turned to Chief Deputy Lonnie Kirks. She knew he would be wondering what was going on. Swallowing a sigh, she held the steering wheel firmly with her left hand, leaned to her right, opened the glove box, and withdrew her cell phone.

She punched in her office number. The call was answered on the first ring.

"Windtree County Sheriff’s Department."

"Hi, Lonnie. Fallon here. Glad to hear you’re on duty."

"Well from the scanner chatter, I knew something was up. I just didn’t know what," he answered curtly.

"So . . . what’s going on over there?" She deliberately ignored his complaint. He had a valid point and she knew it. Since he was her chief deputy, she should have called him. But old habits are not easily changed.

As a Chicago detective, when a call had come in, it had been her duty to get to the crime scene quickly. Next time, God forbid, she would call Lonnie before rushing to the site of a killing.

"Couple of reporters have called from the radio stations," Kirks said. "They heard the same scanner chatter I did. Wanted to know what’s going on. Said they’d like to get the story before their morning news casts end."

"Tell them we’ve found a man knifed. Name’s being withheld pending notification of next of kin. We don’t know yet how long he’s been dead, but the killing apparently happened more than a day ago. We’ll release more details later. Fax that out to all of the local media . . . newspapers, too. That should hold them off for a while. Anything else?"

"Yeah. George Fillet wants to know what’s going on."

Fallon sighed. Fillet was the Windtree County Board Chairman. He was used to getting inside information on crimes in the county. He also liked to share what he knew with his buddies in the local coffee shop. It cemented his reputation with local voters.

In this case, Magare wondered if it might not also provide a pipeline of inside information to a killer.

"Anybody else?" Fallon pressed.

"Yeah. Apparently lots of people were listening to their scanners."

"Had a busy morning, huh?"

"You could say that. But since I didn’t know what was going on, I didn’t have much to tell them."

Fallon winced at his renewed complaint. "Well, tell Mike Jaynts to take over the phones, and tell him there’s still nothing to tell those folks. They can get their questions answered by the news reports. And for now, the only inside information Fillet gets is that the victim’s Olny Parkman."

"Yeah?"

"Yeah. Found in one of Matty Williams’ fields. And Lonnie, I want you over at his place as soon as you get Mike filled in on his duties. We’ve got the crime techs arriving there in about twenty minutes. I need you there."

"Yes, Ma’am," Kirks snapped.

"Lonnie, I’m glad you came in to the office to cover this. That was a good move. Also, I took my own car this morning, so I’m going home to get my cruiser. In the meantime, keep that mob off our backs and keep what you tell our politico-types to a minimum. Okay?"

"Sure. They won’t like it. But if that’s the way you want it, fine by me."

Fallon could hear a self-satisfied grin in his voice. She shifted uncomfortably in her seat and answered, "It might not be the way I want it, but it’s the way I think we need to handle it for now."

*****

Fallon punched off her cell phone and returned it to the glove compartment. Glancing at the fields as her car roared past them, she wondered how best to deal with her chief deputy.

As a detective in Chicago, she had enjoyed a free hand to plow forward in murder investigations. She had never had to mend bent egos within the department. Plus, she knew that Kirks was sensitive to her treatment.

Kirks had been chief deputy and heir apparent when Sheriff Gentry Woulds had announced his retirement. Then Woulds had called her and asked her to run for his seat.

"What about Lonnie?" she had asked.

"He’s too young," Gentry had barked. "He'll be ready someday. You bring him along. Now, don't misunderstand me. I see good things in that boy, and he's a damned good shot, too. Like having our own private SWAT team. But for now, the county’s changing. We need someone over here with more experience than Lonnie has yet. Frankly, Fallon, we need you."

Fallon had said yes to Gentry’s request immediately. And she hadn’t regretted it. She had known with Gentry backing her that she was as good as elected. The county liked him. He could name whom he pleased as his successor, and the voters would back his decision.

Still, her arrival in Windtree County could not have been easy for Lonnie. He had already been circulating his petitions to run for sheriff. But at one word from Woulds, Kirks had pulled his petitions and stepped aside in her favor.

Fallon owed him. And she knew it.

© 2001 M. E. Fuller. All rights reserved.